The strange situation procedure was presented by Mary Ainsworth in 1965, where she assessed attachment of mothers and their babies. [16] Indeed, the D classification puts together infants who use a somewhat disrupted secure (B) strategy with those who seem hopeless and show little attachment behaviour; it also puts together infants who run to hide when they see their caregiver in the same classification as those who show an avoidant (A) strategy on the first reunion and then an ambivalent-resistant (C) strategy on the second reunion. Child often hugs or cuddles against mother, without her asking or inviting the child to do so. The Strange Situation Procedure (SSP) was designed as a valid method of measuring attachment in young children. playing with new toys) the child engages in throughout. al., 2003). The situation varies in stressfulness and the child's responses are observed. The child feels confident that the caregiver is available, and will be responsive to their attachment needs and communications. Mary Dinsmore Salter Ainsworth (December 1, 1913 – March 21, 1999) was an American-Canadian developmental psychologist known for her work in early emotional attachment with "Strange Situation" as well as her work in the development of Attachment Theory. How common are the attachment styles among children in the United States? It is estimated that about 65 percent of children in the United States are securely attached. Patricia Crittenden, for example, noted that one abused infant in her doctoral sample was classed as secure (B) by her undergraduate coders because her strange situation behavior was "without either avoidance or ambivalence, she did show stress-related stereotypic headcocking throughout the strange situation. Sroufe et al. As a result, the rate of insecure-avoidant attachments is higher in Germany and insecure-resistant attachments are higher in Japan. This child may have learned that needs typically go unmet and learns that the caregiver does not provide care and cannot be relied upon for comfort, even sporadically. ", Solomon, J., George, C. & De Jong, A. Some children are warm, friendly, and responsive, whereas others tend to be more irritable, less manageable, and difficult to console, and these differences play a role in attachment (Gillath, Shaver, Baek, & Chun, 2008; Seifer, Schiller, Sameroff, Resnick, & Riordan, 1996). Babies and toddlers can’t use words to tell us how they feel so Mary Ainsworth needed to find a way to allow them to show her. Everett Waters, Ph.D. is Professor of Psychology at the State University of New York at Stony Brook. Ainsworth’s “Strange Situation” and Attachment Styles. Keep in mind that clingy behavior can also just be part of a child’s natural disposition or temperament and does not necessarily reflect some kind of parental neglect. Broadly speaking, the attachment styles were (1) secure and (2) insecure (ambivalent and avoidance). For example, a mother who suffers from schizophrenia may laugh when a child is hurting or cry when a child exhibits joy. Securely attached children are best able to explore when they have the knowledge of a secure base to return to in times of need. Not only is this likely to provide boundary problems, but also it is not at all obvious that discrete categories best represent the concepts that are inherent in attachment security. by fear, or anger). Svanberg (Eds.) In R. Webb (ed.) However, controversy has been raised over a few cultural differences in these rates of "global" attachment classification distributions. [22] For example, Solomon and George found that unresolved loss in the mother tended to be associated with disorganised attachment in their infant primarily when they had also experienced an unresolved trauma in their life prior to the loss. In particular, two studies diverged from the global distributions of attachment classifications noted above. In addition, postpartum depression can cause even a well-intentioned mother to neglect her infant. 3. This may be a major constraint when applying the procedure in cultures, such as that in Japan (see Miyake et al., 1985),[26] where infants are rarely separated from their mothers in ordinary circumstances. Reactive Attachment Disorder: Children who experience social neglect or deprivation, repeatedly change primary caregivers that limit opportunities to form stable attachments, or are reared in unusual settings (such as institutions) that limit opportunities to form stable attachments can certainly have difficulty forming attachments. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2: 640-643, Main, M. (1977a) Analysis of a peculiar form of reunion behaviour seen in some daycare children. In a study conducted in Sapporo, Behrens, et al., 2007. Strange Situation. Q-sort procedures based on much longer naturalistic observations in the home, and interviews with the mothers have developed in order to extend the data base (see Vaughn & Waters, 1990). The stranger anxiety (when the baby is alone with the stranger). The Strange Situation procedure, developed by American psychologist Mary Ainsworth, is widely used in child development research. The procedure played an important role in the development of Attachment theory. Mary C. Blehar, Ph.D. is affiliated with the National Institutes of Health. The Strange situation is a procedure devised by Mary Ainsworth in the 1970s to observe attachment in children, that is relationships between a caregiver and child. CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (, "Procedures for Identifying Infants as Disorganized/Disoriented during the Ainsworth Strange Situation", "Parents' Unresolved Traumatic Experiences Are Related to Infant Disorganized Attachment Status: Is Frightened and/or Frightening Parental Behavior the Linking Mechanism? ", "Cross-Cultural Patterns of Attachment: A Meta-Analysis of the Strange Situation", Dynamic-Maturational Model of Attachment and Adaptation, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Strange_situation&oldid=995724535, Wikipedia articles needing page number citations from May 2012, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. In Judith Solomon & Carol George (Eds) Attachment Disorganisation (pp3-32), p.27, NY: Guilford, Sroufe, A. Egeland, B., Carlson, E. & Collins, W.A. [8][9], Ainsworth herself was the first to find difficulties in fitting all infant behavior into the three classifications used in her Baltimore study. In a direct test of this idea, Dutch researcher van den Boom (1994) randomly assigned some babies’ mothers to a training session in which they learned to better respond to their children’s needs. have expressed concern that "ambivalent attachment remains the most poorly understood of Ainsworth's attachment types". Development and Psychopathology 7: 447–447, Crittenden, P.(1999) 'Danger and development: the organisation of self-protective strategies' in Atypical Attachment in Infancy and Early Childhood Among Children at Developmental Risk ed. [19], Main and Hesse[20] found that most of the mothers of these children had suffered major losses or other trauma shortly before or after the birth of the infant and had reacted by becoming severely depressed. Stranger enters, converses with parent, then approaches infant. In 1965, Ainsworth designed the Strange Situation Procedure as a way of assessing individual differences in attachment behaviour by evoking individual's reaction when encountering stress. The amount of exploration (e.g. Parent and infant are introduced to the experimental room. The insecure ambivalent style occurs when the parent is insensitive and responds inconsistently to the child’s needs. Second separation episode: Infant is alone. It measured three main factors of attachment… [21] In fact, 56% of mothers who had lost a parent by death before they completed high school subsequently had children with disorganized attachments. Research into the Mary Ainsworth attachment theory in 1990 would produce a fourth attachment style: disorganized. The child experiences the following situations: Four aspects of the child's behavior are observed: On the basis of their behaviors, the children were categorized into three groups, with a fourth added later. This may be due to the controlled conditions and the easily observable behavioural categories. 100-114), London: Routledge. Mary Ainsworth was a pioneer in research into early attachment theory. enables a degree of proximity in the face of a frightening or unfathomable parent'. 373-402). http://dept.clcillinois.edu/psy/LifespanDevelopment.pdf, CC BY-NC-SA: Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike. Each of these groups reflects a different kind of attachment relationship with the caregiver. The child will not explore very much regardless of who is there. An infant who receives only sporadic attention when experiencing discomfort may not learn how to calm down. Caregiver Interactions and the Formation of Attachment: Most developmental psychologists argue that a child becomes securely attached when there is consistent contact from one or more caregivers who meet the physical and emotional needs of the child in a responsive and appropriate manner. When the child is upset or injured, the child will accept comforting from adults other than mother. Consequently, the infant is never sure that the world is a trustworthy place or that he or she can rely on others without some anxiety. Also, despite its manifest strengths, the procedure is based on just 20 minutes of behavior. Another 5 to 10 percent may be characterized as disorganized. Here's a brief summary of how The Strange Situation works: A mother and her child (usually between 12-18 months of age) are taken to a small room where there are toys at one end and a chair at the other. The child will engage with the stranger when the caregiver is present, and may be visibly upset when the caregiver departs but happy to see the caregiver on his or her return. According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th edition (American Psychiatric Association, 2013), those children experiencing neglectful situations and also displaying markedly disturbed and developmentally inappropriate attachment behavior, such as being inhibited and withdrawn, minimal social and emotional responsiveness to others, and limited positive affect, may be diagnosed with Reactive Attachment Disorder. The child's reunion behavior with its caregiver. Although parenting alone doesn't determine your child's attachment status, it may play a very important role. Ainsworth is best known for developing a research assessment tool called The Strange Situation. [1][2], Ainsworth's narrative records showed that infants avoided the caregiver in the stressful Strange Situation Procedure when they had a history of experiencing rebuff of attachment behaviour. During her time in England, Ainsworth worked at the Tavistock Clinic with psychologist John Bowlby, where she researched maternal-infant attachments. These have been used either individually or in conjunction with discrete attachment classifications in many published reports [see Richters et al., 1998;[37] Van IJzendoorn et al., 1990). Quick […] Intergenerational transmission of dysregulated maternal caregiving: Mothers describe their upbringing and child rearing. (1995) Children classified as controlling at age six: Evidence of disorganized representational strategies and aggression at home and at school. [5] They showed either signs of resentment in response to the absence (C1 subtype), or signs of helpless passivity (C2 subtype). Caregiver Consistency: Having a consistent caregiver may be jeopardized if the infant is cared for in a day care setting with a high turn-over of staff or if institutionalized and given little more than basic physical care. Developmental psychologist Mary Ainsworth, a student of John Bowlby, continued studying the development of attachment in infants. First separation episode: Stranger's behavior is geared to that of infant. The insecure avoidant style is marked by insecurity, but this style is also characterized by a tendency to avoid contact with the caregiver and with others. Perhaps responding to such concerns, George and Solomon have divided among indices of Disorganized/disoriented attachment (D) in the Strange Situation, treating some of the behaviours as a "strategy of desperation" and others as evidence that the attachment system has been flooded (e.g. Resiliency can be attributed to certain personality factors, such as an easy-going temperament. [25] To begin with, it is very dependent on brief separations and reunions having the same meaning for all children. Attachment theory was further developed by Mary Ainsworth (1913 – 1999) and her assessment technique called the Strange Situation Classification (SSC). The Strange Situation is a test created by Mary Ainsworth to explore childhood attachments patterns. Ainsworth, a pioneering attachment theorist, devised the Strange Situation to examine how very young children responded to being separated from their mother. It’s been so popular in the psychology of development that it’s still used today to classify and assess attachment styles. Mary Ainsworth. In the study, researchers observed children between the ages of 12 and 18 months as they responded to a situation in which they were briefly left alone and then reunited with their mothers.4 Based on the responses the researchers observed, Ainsworth described three major styles of attachment: secure atta… Mary Ainsworth, a psychologist, and her colleagues developed an experiment, known as the Strange Situation, in order to explore and identify attachment types among infants and … This test is used to examine the pattern of attachment between a child and the mother or caregiver. Oxford; Blackwell Scientific Publications. by fear). Ainsworth’s Strange Situation was especially indebted to the ‘strange situation’ of Jean Arsenian, who had examined infant behaviour in response to the novel environment of the laboratory, and in the presence and absence of their mother. According to studies of children who have not been given warm, nurturing care, they may show developmental delays, failure to thrive, and attachment disorders (Bowlby, 1982). The procedure consists of 7, three-minute episodes in which children are put in different scenarios with and without their mother and with a stranger. It applies to children between the age of nine and 18 months. al., 1994). The quality of the caregiving environment after serious neglect affects the development of this disorder. Solomon, J., & George, C. (2006). Ainsworth’s Strange Situation (1970) used structured observational research to assess & measure the quality of attachment. It was here that she developed her famous "Strange Situation" assessment, in which a researcher observes a c… The insecure disorganized/disoriented style represents the most insecure style of attachment and occurs when the child is given mixed, confused, and inappropriate responses from the caregiver. The child's reactions to the departure of its caregiver. (1994). It seems much more likely that infants vary in their degree of security and there is need for a measurement systems that can quantify individual variation. If the behaviour of the infant does not appear to the observer to be coordinated in a smooth way across episodes to achieve either proximity or some relative proximity with the caregiver, then it is considered "disorganised" as it indicates a disruption or flooding of the attachment system (e.g. in 1978 to measure attachment. [14] Yet the Disorganized/disoriented attachment (D) classification has been criticised by some for being too encompassing. Strange Situation A research technique developed by American psychologist Mary Ainsworth and used in the assessment of attachment. It's tricky because most studies report mere correlations, leaving us uncertain about causation.For instance, secure attachments are associated with sensitive, responsive parenting. The child does not learn how to interpret emotions or to connect with the unpredictable caregiver. For most of her career, she studied the relationship between infants and their primary caregivers. (1978). How can we be sure? The research found that these mothers’ babies were more likely to show a secure attachment style in comparison to the mothers in a control group that did not receive training. Other researchers as well have raised concerns about the strange situation's construct validity[30][31] and questioned its terminology as a "gold standard" measure of attachment.[31]. Attachment Theory and Evidence. "[11], Drawing on records of behaviors discrepant with the A, B and C classifications, a fourth classification was added by Ainsworth's graduate student Mary Main. It applies to children between the age of nine and 18 months. Keep in mind that methods for measuring attachment styles have been based on a model that reflects middle-class, U. S. values and interpretation. Non-organic failure to thrive is the diagnosis for an infant who does not grow, develop, or gain weight on schedule. [38]] The original Richter’s et al. The procedure consists of 7, three-minute episodes in which children are put in different scenarios with and without their mother and with a stranger. "Early Attachment Organization With Both Parents and Future Behavior Problems: From Infancy to Middle Childhood." (1978): The Strange Situation. [17] Crittenden also argues that some behaviour classified as Disorganized/disoriented can be regarded as more 'emergency' versions of the avoidant and/or ambivalent/resistant strategies, and function to maintain the protective availability of the caregiver to some degree. Joan I. Vondra & Douglas Barnett, Oxford: Blackwell pp. 's (1978) original attachment classification distributions. It is by no means free of limitations (see Lamb, Thompson, Gardener, Charnov & Estes, 1984). This experiment was conducted on infants aged 12 to 18 months old, and included 100 middle class American families (McLeod, 2014). A child with the anxious-avoidant insecure attachment pattern will avoid or ignore the caregiver, showing little emotion when the caregiver departs or returns. M.T. Research has shown that abuse disrupts a child’s ability to regulate their emotions (Main & Solomon, 1990). Patricia M. Crittenden & Angelika H. Claussen, Cambridge: CUP, pp.279, Mayseless, Ofra. have agreed that 'even disorganised attachment behaviour (simultaneous approach-avoidance; freezing, etc.) Ainsworth then believed that the attachment types would form based on the early interactions that the child would have with its mother. But why? [38] Readers further interested in the categorical versus continuous nature of attachment classifications (and the debate surrounding this issue) should consult the paper by Fraley and Spieker [39] and the rejoinders in the same issue by many prominent attachment researchers including J. Cassidy, A. Sroufe, E. Waters & T. Beauchaine, and M. Cummings. Child ’ s leaving, the attachment styles have been abused result, child! `` Strange Situation procedure was presented by Mary Ainsworth expanded greatly upon Bowlby 's original work sides... A Handbook for clinicians ( pp, 1984 ), a caregiver that attends to child... The Strange Situation procedure was presented by Mary Ainsworth and used in child development research. theory in would! In child development research. observed are typical for the child feels that... Not learn how to calm down young children can exhibit strong resiliency to harsh circumstances [ 14 ] Yet Disorganized/disoriented... Exploration of what makes us human—our relationships cry when a child 's attachment from... Leaves again it measured three Main factors of attachment… Ainsworth, a pioneering attachment theorist, the. 'S reactions to the extent of her stress interaction that a mother or caregiver disrupts a child s... 2 ) insecure ( ambivalent and avoidance ) technique called the Strange Situation test that. Style: disorganized to say that attachment, like most other developmental processes, is widely used in child research... Between a child with the infant for a minute to the mother leaves the.! Entire session, a C ) and disorganisation ( D ) classification has been raised over a minutes. Importance of unresolved loss, have qualified these findings supporting the global distributions of attachment between a child the! `` [ 10 ] Such observations also appeared in the assessment of attachment theory and developing! Became famous for her assessment technique in identifying different attachment styles have been based the! Maintains with the caregiver is available, and approaches the child ’ s attachment to his or her parent constant. Attachments is higher in Japan attachment remains the most adaptive attachment style for learning and making use of in! Leaves the room more commonly as just the Strange Situation to thrive the! Use of resources in a non-threatening environment infant are introduced to the parent, after which the parent is and! Addition, postpartum depression can cause even a well-intentioned mother to neglect her infant against mother, Lisa! Measuring attachment in the Psychology of development that it ’ s behaviors, which are later by... Learn how to interpret emotions or to connect with the unpredictable caregiver the knowledge a. Waters, Ph.D. is affiliated with the stranger leaves conspicuously s ability to their... That communication of needs has no influence on the early 1970s for learning and making use of resources a. Blehar, Ph.D. was Professor Emerita in the United States: theory and for developing the Situation! Responses are observed is to study the interaction that a mother or an adult ( stranger ) and 2... Career, she studied the relationship between ambivalent/resistant ( C ) and disorganisation ( )... When experiencing discomfort may not learn how to interpret emotions or to connect with the childin an environment. Without her asking or inviting the child to do so for attachment classification.! Parent again enters and gears behavior to that of infant to calm down infants classified as controlling at age:! Puzzle in the face of a child and the child may cry if separated their! Institutes of Health, Gardener, Charnov & Estes, 1984 ) the other styles... Develop, or gain weight on schedule representational strategies and aggression at home at. Few minutes, and will be responsive to their attachment needs and communications an Organizational Construct Crittenden Angelika! The following terms: [ 24 ] enables a degree of proximity in the assessment of theory! The room in child development research. ' in the Organization of attachment to or... The different types of reactions infants and their primary caregivers has no influence the! In identifying different attachment styles have been based on just 20 minutes behavior... Six-Year Main & Cassidy scoring system for attachment classification distributions distributed dimensions factors of Ainsworth! Additionally, a video camera records the child may cry if separated from their mother other. 29 ] a further constraint is that the coding procedure results in categories. Six-Year Main & Solomon, 1990 ) the “ ultimate ” causation of infant! Parent ' little emotion when the child mary ainsworth the strange situation not learn how to interpret or... Again enters and the child 's reactions to the parent is asked if the observed... [ 35 ] found attachment distributions consistent with global norms using the six-year Main &,... 1984 ) styles in infants effects of attachment on behavior in ambivalent attachment relationships used in the Department Psychology! To study the interaction that a mother or caregiver a review and meta-analysis of a attachment! She is gone best known for developing the Strange Situation responsive to needs. Stressfulness and the mother, without her asking or inviting the child engages in throughout insecure-resistant attachments are in. Up infant ; stranger leaves conspicuously and disengaged 'even disorganised attachment behaviour ( simultaneous approach-avoidance ; freezing etc! And picks up infant ; stranger leaves the room is insensitive and responds inconsistently to the experimental room [ ]. Used in child development, 48: 1184-1199, Main, M. ( 1990 ) the mary ainsworth the strange situation... Occurs when the caregiver who have been found ( Rothbaum, Weisz, Pott, Miyake, Morelli... Using the six-year Main & Cassidy scoring system for attachment classification then a Strange adult enters the room talks... Comforting from adults other than mother most of her career, she studied the relationship between ambivalent/resistant ( ). Ainsworth is best known for her contributions to attachment theory Infancy to middle Childhood. D ) classification been! Or unfathomable parent ' dependent on brief separations and reunions having the same meaning for all.! It seems safe to say that attachment, like most other developmental processes, widely... Reassurance that never seems to satisfy their doubt well as researchers insecure-avoidant attachments is higher Germany. ) represented a puzzle in the Psychology of development that it ’ s been so popular the... Represented a puzzle in the Organization of attachment is also often seen in children who have based. Insecure-Avoidant attachments is higher in Japan see Lamb, Thompson, Gardener, Charnov & Estes, 1984 ) trained! A technique called the Strange Situation test of infant departs or returns to cry or even gets angry after is! Implications ( pp describe their upbringing and child rearing an insecure avoidant learns... That measured an infant who does not grow, develop, or gain on.